Addressing emission regulations


Andrew Keith, Product Development Director at Cressall Resistors, discusses the changes to emissions regulations and what they mean for power maintenance

Air pollution is now the biggest environmental risk to public health in the UK. As unregulated medium-sized combustion plants (MCPs) and generators are a known source of significant air pollution, addressing their environmental impact is crucial.

Toxic air leads to an estimated 400,000 premature deaths in Europe each year. The UK’s attitude towards this issue has been troublesome; its breach of EU air quality limits resulted in a referral to Europe’s highest court in 2018. To address these grave levels of pollution, the UK government passed new restrictions that mean those using generators need to review their efficiency.

Tougher controls

Many of the generators currently in use are older designs, contributing to air quality concerns and making a significant dent in the National Emission Ceilings (NEC) Directive’s nitrogen oxides (NOx) allowance. Passed in 2018, the Medium Combustion Plant Directive (MCPD), together with the Specified Generator Regulations, ushered in the first phase of strict emission limits on combustion plants operating between one and 50 MWth.

Under the regulations, generator operators must hold an environmental permit that relates to the date that their equipment began to comply with the rules. Generators must also meet the reduced NOx emission limit of 190 mg/Nm3 and have no persistent visible emissions of dark smoke.

The transition from complying with previous regulations to the current requirements depends on the age of the generator. Newer generators have needed to comply from January 2019 onwards. However, most of the question marks surround the use of existing assets, which need to comply from as late as 2030.

The regulations are expected to provide 43% of the sulphur dioxide emissions reduction, 9% of the reduction for particulate matter and 22% of the NOx emissions reduction needed to meet the UK’s 2030 emissions targets.

The escape clause

However, the rules come with loopholes. Exempt from the updated restrictions are back-up or standby generators that operate for the purpose of testing for no more than 50 hours per year. Those that run for longer can also be excluded, but operators would need to demonstrate a genuine need for this additional testing.

Although the majority of back-up generators can avoid complying with these restrictions, this doesn’t mean that we should not address their efficiency. Running a standby generator is key to ensuring its longevity, so although these generators may remain unused for long periods of time, regular load testing is crucial to help them continue to run efficiently.

Load testing doesn’t only extend the lifespan of generators; diesel standby generators that run rarely or on light loads can build up fuel deposits in parts of the engine with time, which may lead to a generator producing a reduced output capacity when it’s required to work.

This potentially hazardous build-up is known as wet stacking and causes the generator to emit harmful smoke. Many urban areas restrict the level of smoke emissions that wet stacking produces, making efforts to reduce its occurrence an important step towards reducing air pollution.

Load bank testing

Effective load bank testing helps to combat wet stacking. When running at maximum output, the temperature and pressure in an engine increase to levels that cannot be reached when running lighter loads. This increased input helps to vaporise the fuel and soot deposits that have built up in the engine’s exhaust chamber, reducing the effect of wet stacking.

Supplementary load

An alternative to intermittent load bank testing is to use a lower rated load bank combined with load detection control in a set-up known as dummy or ballast loading. This arrangement closely monitors the site load so that it falls below the optimum loading of the generator; the load bank is energised to top up the site load.

Dummy loading also ensures the generator is running at its most efficient operating point and the exhaust gases are at the optimum temperature, avoiding black smoke emissions. Load banks for this purpose can be standalone units or integrated into the generator package.

Although standby generators are currently exempt from the MCPD, this doesn’t mean that we shouldn’t address their contribution towards harmful emissions. Not only will this contribute towards our goal for cleaner air, but effective load bank testing will also help to improve equipment longevity and prevent the need for costly maintenance.