Monitoring solvent emissions to ensure compliance

With more than 40 years of experience in designing VOC analysers, Signal Group has specialised in developing instruments that enable process operators to demonstrate compliance; and, in the following article, Stephane Canadas explains the vital role of monitoring

Governments from around the world have implemented environmental regulations to reduce the emissions of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) from industrial processes. For example, according to the European Solvents Industry Group, total VOC emissions in the EU have been reduced by more than 60% since 1990.

VOCs are released from industrial activities that utilise organic chemicals such as solvents, as well as from engines and incinerators that burn organic materials and fuels.

Both types of application require similar monitoring equipment, but this article will focus on those applications that involve solvents.

Solvents are used widely in the chemical industry, for cleaning and degreasing products and machinery and/or dissolving, thinning and dispersing coatings, adhesives, paints and inks.

Solvents evaporate readily at room temperature and represent a significant safety hazard in the workplace, so they are generally vented away from workers and the emissions from such vents frequently require abatement prior to release.

Solvent emissions have to be minimised because of their environmental effects, which include the formation of ozone, a constituent of photochemical smog.

At ground level, ozone is generated when VOCs react with nitrogen oxides (NOx) in the presence of sunlight. Ozone can have both acute and chronic effects on humans, affecting the respiratory, cardiovascular and central nervous system, as well as reproductive health. Ground level ozone can also have harmful effects on vegetation and sensitive ecosystems.

Stephane Canadas

In most countries, the emissions of regulated processes with the potential to release VOCs are issued with permits that include an emission limit for total organic carbon (TOC).

The standard reference method for the measurement of TOC is with a flame ionisation detector (FID). In some cases, it may be necessary for the monitoring activity to speciate toxic VOCs or to distinguish between methane and non-methane VOCs.

European VOC Solvent Emissions Directive (SED)

The main objective of the SED is to reduce the emissions of VOCs. Operators have two main compliance options; they may demonstrate compliance with a VOC emission limit value and fugitive emission limits by submitting monitoring data.

This data will either include annual or continuous monitoring results depending on the size of process’s VOC emissions. Alternatively, processes may use a solvent reduction approach to achieve the results that would be obtained from meeting a mass emission limit.

The reduction scheme enables the operator to attain emission reductions that are equivalent to those that would have been achieved if the emission limit values were to be applied. This could be by substituting products with a high solvent content for low solvent or solvent free products and/or changing to solvent free production processes.

Under the SED, regulators require continuous monitoring when the average emission, following abatement, is more than 10 kg/h of total organic carbon. Continuous monitoring is also required when the regulator considers it necessary to demonstrate compliance with VOC emission limits.

If continuous monitoring is not necessary, the regulator will require periodic measurements. For periodic measurements of VOC(s), at least three readings must be obtained during each measurement exercise.

When there is consistent compliance with emission limits, regulators may consider reducing the monitoring frequency requirement. However, the monitoring frequency should be increased, for example, as part of the commissioning of new or substantially changed activities or when emission levels are close to the emission concentration limits.

Clearly, VOC monitoring, both continuous and periodic, has a key role to play in demonstrating compliance. However, Signal’s customers also use FIDs to measure the effects of mitigation measures, to check the performance of abatement equipment, for process control and to investigate diffuse emissions.

Reducing VOC emissions in the US

In the United States, the Clean Air Act is a federal law regulating air emissions from stationary and mobile sources.

The Act authorises the United States Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA) to establish National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) to protect public health and to regulate the emissions of hazardous air pollutants. The EPA has therefore published a list of hazardous air pollutants, many of which are VOCs.

VOCs can contribute to non-attainment with the NAAQS or may adversely affect the attainment status of an area. The EPA has addressed serious violations through enforcement actions, achieving measurable pollutant reductions and improving air quality.

Through partnerships with state and tribal authorities, the US EPA has conducted multiple joint inspections and enforcement actions, which has resulted in a significant reduction of VOC emissions, particularly from the oil and gas sector.

MiniFID + heated line

In the US, Method 25 is applicable for the determination of VOCs (measured as total gaseous non-methane organics [TGNMO] and reported as carbon) in stationary source emissions.

The Method states: Direct measurement of an effluent with a flame ionisation detector (FID) analyser may be appropriate with prior characterisation of the gas stream and knowledge that the detector responds predictably to the organic compounds in the stream.

If present, methane (CH4) will, of course, also be measured. The FID can be used under any of the following limited conditions:

  • when only one compound is known to exist
  • when the organic compounds consist of only hydrogen and carbon
  • when the relative percentages of the compounds are known or can be determined, and the FID responses to the compounds are known
  • when a consistent mixture of the compounds exists before and after emission control and only the relative concentrations are to be assessed
  • when the FID can be calibrated against mass standards of the compounds emitted (solvent emissions, for example).

Another example of the use of a direct FID is as a screening method. If there is enough information available to provide a rough estimate of the FID analyser accuracy, it can be used to determine the VOC content of an uncharacterised gas stream.

With a sufficient buffer to account for possible inaccuracies, the direct FID can be a useful tool to obtain the desired results without costly exact determination.

Alternatively, Method 25A applies to the determination of total gaseous organic concentration of vapours consisting primarily of alkanes, alkenes and/or aromatic hydrocarbons.

The concentration is expressed in terms of propane (or other appropriate organic calibration gas) or in terms of carbon. Again, the Method stipulates the collection of a heated gas sample that’s passed to a flame ionisation analyser.

VOC monitoring

As outlined above, the level of monitoring required by regulators is dictated by the scale of an operator’s VOC emissions, with continuous monitoring needed for larger emitters and discontinuous monitoring for processes with lower emissions.

Signal Group has therefore developed VOC analysers to meet both requirements — a portable heated FID (Signal MiniFID 3010) for periodic measurements and a continuous heated FID (SOLAR) for permanent installations.

The continuous heated FID SOLAR analyser can be easily fitted into a 19” rack cabinet for indoor or outdoor installation. The analyser has an embedded microprocessor that automatically starts the process upon receipt of a command from a detachable tablet … or from a remote installation with Signal’s S4i software.

This command sets in place a sequence of actions that prepare the analyser to take samples and report calibrated readings to the instrument’s internal datalogger.

Using an optional detachable tablet, users are able to manage the analyser wirelessly up to 50 metres away. In addition, using the remote S4i software with an Ethernet connection, the analyser can be operated from anywhere at any time.

This remote accessibility also means that the Signal after-sales team can monitor alarms, conduct remote calibration and even troubleshoot if necessary.

The portable heated FID MiniFID 3010 is suitable for a variety of applications, including

  • compliance monitoring when the permit requires discontinuous measurements
  • calibration of CEMS
  • temporary back-up for CEMS
  • checking abatement performance
  • fugitive emissions investigations
  • process optimisation.

In contrast with most of the other “portable” FIDs on the market, the MiniFID 3010 was designed as a rugged, portable field-use instrument.

With an optional internal datalogger (and memory stick), sample pump, inlet filter, heated line controller and a detachable gas bottle holder, the MiniFID 3010 is ideal for use on ducts and stacks with difficult access.

The analyser’s detachable bottle holder accommodates both the burner gas and the calibration gas, with zero air provided with a background hydrocarbons purifier.

The frame is made from lightweight aluminium and the instrument is supplied with lifting eyes and a comfortable shoulder strap. Portable FIDs often need to operate with extended power cables, so the MiniFID is able to operate without a power-hungry microprocessor.

The heated line (optional 5 or 10 m) is powered from a socket on the side of the analyser, which helps to reduce the amount of cabling required. The heated line is supplied with a stainless-steel sintered filter probe for insertion into the stack or duct.

Summary

FID analysers are ideal for a variety of solvent emissions monitoring applications; the list given in Method 25 provides a useful guide. It is important to remember that although flame ionisation is the reference method for the monitoring of VOCs, the response of the analyser will vary according to the VOC or VOCs present in the sample.

Companies